Which is more appealing? GS or GW PDF Print E-mail
Written by Noin   
Monday, 24 July 2006
Noin
December 15th, 2004, 04:12 PM
I remember back in the day when I found out about Gundam Wing.:D I thought it was so cool. I started watching the episodes and I was really into it. I guess I could even call it my inspiration that led me to start drawing. :sdrop3:

Now this "sorta" new series, Gundam Seed has been out.. I hear it's also quite as popular as Gundam Wing.. I've seen an episode or two but I don't think I'm as addicted to it as Gundam Wing.. I think it's the art style for me :meh:

so yeah take the poll and explain yourselves :p

Hampstergeddon
December 15th, 2004, 04:15 PM
theres no "raunchy raunchy sex" option.

BlitzZ
December 15th, 2004, 07:42 PM
:(no UC?

Kuwabara
December 16th, 2004, 10:06 AM
Gundam wing rules

aznkit
December 16th, 2004, 06:30 PM
i really really really don like it (i hate it) well in GW theres like a better plot the characters r so much more developed (and their cuter)

Saosin
December 16th, 2004, 06:40 PM
theres no "raunchy raunchy sex" option.X'D

I've only seen GW, but I know i'd like it more than GS. well I have seen some of GS and I liked GW better.

kagome is so hot
December 16th, 2004, 06:47 PM
umm well gs is about a totally gay littly sissy bitch so yea um gundam wing kicks gundam seeds ass and it allways will :p

Strider Hiryu
December 16th, 2004, 10:06 PM
I'll say neither. I'm not a huge fan of GW anymore and I've never been a fan of GS so neither are appealing in my eyes. Now if you had a UC series up there that'd be a different story.

Eppy
December 16th, 2004, 10:50 PM
i have a feeling this topic is gonna turn into another flame bitch fight like the last gundam topic

Kuwabara
December 17th, 2004, 10:05 AM
don't worry its not because thats why i have the gundam disccusion topic

BlitzZ
December 17th, 2004, 05:12 PM
yes,we will keep it calm,right?

aznkit
December 17th, 2004, 08:09 PM
yep:happy:

Flying_Monkey
January 8th, 2005, 03:00 PM
GS is only good when I'm bored out of my misery and there is nothin else to watch, but even then it isn't all that entertaining.

GW is way better.

DeathscytheX
January 8th, 2005, 06:56 PM
I liked GW's story better. Im not a big fan of the whole CG art used in GS.

GundamFreakX
January 8th, 2005, 08:28 PM
It's GW 4 me. I'm not that interested in the GS story.

Flying_Monkey
January 9th, 2005, 03:49 PM
Epyon :drool:

Kuwabara
January 10th, 2005, 12:00 PM
epyon is not a real reason because it appears at the end its heero

EVA-01
February 3rd, 2005, 09:03 PM
It's GW 4 me. I'm not that interested in the GS story.


I think that Gundam Seed has been getting better because they now have like an army of gundams and Kira and Artherine teamed up on one of the episodes, and they've been doing more fighting than talking. I didn't like it at first either.

Mike 1508
February 3rd, 2005, 09:42 PM
wing will conqure all

Kuwabara
February 4th, 2005, 10:08 AM
Well strike cant defeat zero
thats another reason

Clowtrigger
March 6th, 2005, 03:52 AM
Well strike cant defeat zero
thats another reason
Freedom Can Defeat Providence............ It has 12/32 Funnels with it..........
Freedom Can Shoot at an Army of Ginns in no time..................
Destiny Can Show of better Wings than Wingzero(Just Love those Beam Wings)
Blast Impulse Has More Firepower than Wing ZERO's TBR...........
Your Conservative ways are too stupid.......... Gundam W is 10 years old...........
SEED Has more cotinuity in its timeline......... If SEED Sucked, Why Would It have a sequel: a second series dated two years after the first...............
Destiny Is up there with the likes of Naruto, Bleach and Mai Hime in Japan.........

Mimiru
March 6th, 2005, 10:46 AM
Ack they both have there draws but GS is getting alot better

K.W
March 6th, 2005, 03:29 PM
I liked GW's story better. Im not a big fan of the whole CG art used in GS.
I agree with that. GS really just annoys me sometimes as well, because, from what i have seen the main character has a bunch of girls that like him(a lot). Heero sorta does, but at least the other girls that like Heero aren't obsessed with him..^_^; Yeah, Im horrible at explaining things.. (btw, i havent seen that much of GS, but enough to know that it looks like a bunch of girls like him)

BlitzZ
March 6th, 2005, 04:31 PM
GS does have some awesome looking gundams, which is one of the only reasons I watch it. The series does have some awesome art. Although GW has a great storyline and characters.
(GS gundams + GW Characters and Plot =:tup::tup: )

Clowtrigger
March 6th, 2005, 08:32 PM
*removed message*

Clowtrigger
March 6th, 2005, 08:39 PM
The Problem Is that you don't open your door for other things...........
SEED Has Become one of Bandai's Masterpieces..............
With 1 OAV,
5 Special Editions
and a Sequel Series Airing in Japan............
It has gone where no Alternate Universe Has Gone Before........

Kuwabara
March 8th, 2005, 05:53 PM
It does not matter the eps Wing has more U.S. Fans and Japan has more Seed because they forgot about Wing. Check any Database on 1995 Anime and you'll see Wing Was at the top.

Why is it that Seed is taking the core MS Gundam? Gundam Wing did its own thing totally independent from the UC Time line seed on the other hand is sraying towards UC.
Coordinators=Newtypes.

Gundam Wing had no peopl with Special Powers they had skill they hadtrue warriors people like **otto** the one who died with tallgeese and others. Treize the wing boys will not hesitate to kill themselves to attain victory i bet Kira probably unisalled his self detenator the coward.

Wufei would hate him if he knew him. Even Quatre has more intrigue than Kira.

Strider Hiryu
March 8th, 2005, 08:08 PM
Kuwabara watch yourself. Your stepping on the lines of pissing me off again. Never and I mean never say any of the UC pilots didn't have skill. You do that and you'll be in way over your head. Keep this to SEED and GW only plz. Do not involve the classics that made the mecha anime franchise what it is today. To do so would definately cement my firm belief that you know nothing of Gundam and are not a true mecha fan.

You should remember that without the original gundam there would be no pretty faced GW and SEED. You should respect the classics, not blatantly disregard them.

DeathscytheX
March 8th, 2005, 08:22 PM
You would also be easily demolished in a SICD RPG X'D

Kuwabara
March 9th, 2005, 10:40 AM
Strider i didn't mean to insult UC cause i watch and admire some UC shows. I meant that seed was copying UC like their imation Zaku's. I meant that Wing did not use special powers unlike Seed where the coordinator's are way stronger than Newtypes. Wing the only thing out of the ordianry to help them pilot was the Zero System.

Strider Hiryu
March 9th, 2005, 11:41 AM
I know but watch yourself when talking about stuff. You have to remember that Newtypes did not ask for their powers, Coordinators did. Newtypes were the next step in human evolution, Coordinator's aren't. They are genetically modified human beings. Remember these things people. Also if you want to get technical Kuwabara the Zero System also bestows some "extraordinary" powers upon its pilots making them just like Coordinators so you can't say everyone in GW was ordinary.

DX: X'D cause its so true.

Kuwabara
March 10th, 2005, 10:19 AM
They were outside of the Zero system. While coordinators where "freaks" in and out of their suits. They ask for their genetic splicing yet kira feels bad when his friends stereotype against him. I don't quite understand why.

Strider Hiryu
March 10th, 2005, 11:20 AM
Doesn't matter, they still have the "extraordinary" abilities inside the suit where if you didn't notice most of the Gundam shows take place from, in combat. So thinking this isn't exactly a matter of piloting skill when all you can do is jump in a suit and be given the ability to predict enemy movements and such. Thats basically all Coordinators are able to do just without the help of a machine to do it for them.

As for Kira feeling bad, wouldn't you. Kira never asked to be a Coordinator. His parents made the choice for him (his parents were naturals if you happened to watch any of it). Thats why when his friends sterotype him he feels bad. He didn't ask to be Genetically Modified nor did he ask to be thrown into the grips of a war where the main reason to fight is because the enemy just happens to be like him. This is why Kira debates his reason for fighting and doesn't want to do it. He has no reason to kill those just like him because he's told. The only reason he fights is to protect the people he loves and they just happen to be onboard an Earth ship yet he fights his best friend, who just happens to be on the wrong side. Now don't tell me that those wouldn't make you think twice about fighting and about what you are cause if you did you'd be lieing.

Kuwabara
March 10th, 2005, 10:13 PM
So Zaft is the coordinator faction. WOW! guess i should have paid more attention to seed instead of falling asleep after 10mins. Maybe i should rewatch it then talk smack. So the whole war revolves arounf the coordinators. YOu see how little i knew about seed but yet watched everyweek.

Clowtrigger
March 10th, 2005, 10:44 PM
Oh and more........
Kira and Athrun in episode 37-50 of seed will become the best gundam duo with Freedom and Justice ........... Kira Feels Bad not only because of that, it is also because of his PAst.......... He was an Experiment...... He is the so-called ultimate coordinator... His Sister.........Cagalli is a natural........ He was taken out of his mother's womb.... and was experimented with......................and eventually, Lacus will help him ease his mind over that sorrow......... decisively changing kira's Ideals. In Destiny, He is currently the Leader of The Archangel Faction, hoping to stop the re-errupting conflict.......... He, like Kenshin Himura.........has a no kill policy........... and I feel sorry that Freedom 2 is actually called NU-Freedom (Nu-Gundam)[Nu is from............... And he is now a successful Experiment I Heard, He now has Newtype powers......... because in ep. 12 of Destiny, He seems to Have sensed something happening to shinn, and if it was somehow explained of how Rau Le Kluuze Sensed Kira Coming, and Kira Sensing that the archangel was in deep shit at the hands of providence........

Kuwabara
March 11th, 2005, 10:05 AM
So what happens to the other gundams? Seed in my opinion is not as appealing as wing. Seed story just keeps making confusing twist to show off the power of coordinators.

TheProphet
March 16th, 2005, 03:00 PM
dont get me wrong... i love wing but seed looks more interesting but it might be that i havent really watched that many episods.

Clowtrigger
March 16th, 2005, 09:03 PM
It's Because it is............................. The Drama of Athrun's Soap Opera...............
The Political Idealisms of Zaft, Orb, EA and The Archangel Faction:
For example:
Zaft: We are Just Protecting ourselves from the threat of the naturals
EA: For a Clean and Blue World ( RAcists)
Orb: We cannot let Orb be burned down Again................... so we need to follow the EA
Archangel Faction: We will have to protect and find the right path............. We will have to stop this meaningless form of aggression.................
Even The Characters have their own Idealisms:
Kira(SEED): Need To protect by killing the enemy...........
Kira(SEED-Destiny): Need To protect the future Generation of humans

Shinn: I need the power to protect the ones i love so that the horrors of my past will never happen again

Athrun: I need to protect PLANT No matter What.............
Cagalli: I need to protect ORb no matter What...............
Lunamaria: Protection against the enemy is essential to life
Lacus(SEED): I need to stop this nonesense........ wars are a result of endless aggression and ignorance.....................
Lacus(SEED Destiny): We need to find our own path.......... a path that would lead us to happiness
Meer: I need to be Lacus to have the power to calm the people.

The coolness of FReedom(Beam Spammer+Samurai-like quickness+ Great Agility+METEOR+NJC+Kira) and Savior(Zeta-Like Transformation+Athrun+Duoble Sword+Double Cannon)............and Soon Destiny(Mirage Colloid+Beam Wings+NJC+Buster Rifle+Anti Ship
Sword+Shinn)

And of course........... customized MS like:
Yzak's Slash Zaku Phantom:(Laser Gattlings+ Beam Pole Axe)

TheProphet
March 16th, 2005, 09:59 PM
wtf..... dident really get all that in! lets read it again...

Kuwabara
March 17th, 2005, 09:14 AM
Wing had more drama.
Pacifism in all aspects were it was debated on how to achieve it.
Heero did not really care for the outcome until Zero but still he was a center of most contravesy.

EVA-01
March 17th, 2005, 09:20 AM
Not many people like Seed here. Only like, 4 or 5 people like it. :(

Kuwabara
March 17th, 2005, 04:56 PM
That's mostly all the forums i use to go to.

Clowtrigger
March 17th, 2005, 09:17 PM
Try These forums, maybe they shed more light on you and youll regret saying 4-5 people like SEED or Destiny, Because if you were there........... you'll find nothing but crispy SEED/UC Topics.:
AnimeNation
Anime Suki
Naruto Forums
GundamWatch
Anime Forums

TheProphet
March 17th, 2005, 09:21 PM
Seed is for younger viewers i think

Clowtrigger
March 17th, 2005, 09:42 PM
Seed is for younger viewers i think
for younger people??
You like Kids to see the main Character's sister's hand be amputated........... LOLZ
You like Kids to see People pop like baloons..................... LOLZ
YOu like Kids to see A Huge Knife Stuck to a cannon fodder's Pilot's Throat........
Seriously SEED............ is a Teen show.............. it features more ideals and drama...... and actually more grewsome than Wing.............like rorouni Kenshin OAV

TheProphet
March 17th, 2005, 09:48 PM
damn.... i havent it watched alote! dont go into defence mode there...

Clowtrigger
March 17th, 2005, 10:00 PM
Those Parts are from the original Version(Subbed) of SEED................. The bastardized version(Dub) is not Good Really.........................
But The Battles in SEED and Destiny are Fast-Paced and Very Good.............
For Example Freedom vs. Providence.....................
Providence is a Funnel User and Freedom was a Beam Spammer............... Just Read the forums in animesuki and animenation......... they like SEED and its Sequel because it is very interesting and very intriguing.............
SEED's Popularity in Japan and in Asia is real.............................. I'm from asai and i've seen 1-50 of seed and 1-21 of destiny.......................... it's really good........... especially the sequel...................

and anyone think of a gundam that can match wingzero's wings.......... here itishttp://www.sunrise-anime.jp/sunnews_pic/image/0503111123430.jpg
its called the Destiny Gundam from Gundam SEED Destiny.................

TheProphet
March 17th, 2005, 11:18 PM
you know a "little" too much... but we all have animes where we know all about them :)

Kuwabara
March 18th, 2005, 09:32 AM
Yo and thats a butterfly's wing and is pretty but Wing Zero had angel wings. Its beautiful and shows power.

EVA-01
March 18th, 2005, 09:40 AM
I forgot what happens at the end og Wing can someone tell me what happens?

Flying_Monkey
March 18th, 2005, 03:41 PM
Fucked if I know I haven't been able to see the entire series

Clowtrigger
March 18th, 2005, 07:02 PM
...........................Libra Gets TBR'd.................................Epyon Lost By a plot Hole.......................................

Endless Waltz Ending:
Gundams Appear............... Get Trashed By Serpents because they were too many..................................
Wing Zero Destroys the Gates............................
Then Wu-fei from being a baddy "Suddenly" Becomes good.....................
Then Dekim.................. Pulls Trigger on Releena, Mariemeia Plays The Body Guard and Dekim Gets Owned......... Then Heero Comes and Gets his toy Pistol...................... then "pulls the Trigger" on Mariemeia

Clowtrigger
March 18th, 2005, 07:32 PM
Yo and thats a butterfly's wing and is pretty but Wing Zero had angel wings. Its beautiful and shows power.
Shows Power?Those Are What You Call Beam Wings.................. Those Wings can Cut Through Metal.................. Destiny has more firepower than what you think.............................. It has a mini positron Laser, an Anti Ship sword ,a Nuclear Fusion Core and Mirage Colloid can be activated while with Phase Shift..............

Kuwabara
March 20th, 2005, 02:19 AM
Wow a bit power hungry i see. Wing was not into all that power. They kept it simple and they still displayed a lot of power.

Flying_Monkey
March 20th, 2005, 04:44 AM
wow that is insane. clowtrigger is insane its so awesome

and yep Kuwabara has a majorly good point so yeah

Strider Hiryu
March 20th, 2005, 04:53 PM
Children settle down. Good lord this fighting is pointless. As I've said multiple times you all have your opinions and its good to voice them but do not go to the point of starting a fight.

If you want the opinion of a true Gundam fan both SEED and Wing were more engrossed with overpowering the suits to the point that only something of their power could destroy them. Don't believe me, well pay closer attention the next time you watch them. In Wing the only thing that can destroy or damage a Gundam is another Gundam, one of the Tallgeese series, a Virgo (be it I or II), or the Mercerius/Vayete (don't mind the spelling). Same in SEED. About the only suits that could damage a Gundam was another Gundam. Now don't tell me that thats not true cause you know it is.

Now if you look at the predecessors before that series (I'm talking UC my friends, yes the great timeline of Universal Century) these suits were more realistic. They could in fact be damaged by anything that attacked them be it a tank, core fighter, normal GM/Zaku, to mobile armors. You see the only thing a Gundam had going for it was the increased armor strength (same goes for AU series but the ones in Wing and SEED were more overly powered then they should have been) and its ability to implement beam weapons into its arsenal (due to increased Powerplant capacity, which normal MS's were given later in different series).

Now get over your power trips and I do mean both of you. Your fanboyism is going to both of your heads and its getting annoying. Just state your opinion and get it over with. If someone goes against it let them unless they blatantly insult you then use information that has been proven and use it to back your opinion. God people like you two really get on my nerves.

Flying_Monkey
March 20th, 2005, 05:04 PM
yes this is true but it is fun to fight over what is better sometimes............

Kuwabara
March 20th, 2005, 07:02 PM
Strider you forget So does G-Gundam only a gundam can defeat a gundam mostly because they were all gundams. But the Bickering needs to sotp it's really pissing me off but i can't help it. Since CLowtrigger came he's done nothing but come after me. I just do this to piss him off. when one say's simple yet true staements it tends to piss people off.

TheProphet
March 20th, 2005, 10:43 PM
i think it was cartoon network who made it seem kiddy to me... it still look better than Wing... sorry even though i lived off wing for 3 years... ( i bought a figure a mounth ago of tallgeeses) i think...

Sabe
March 20th, 2005, 10:47 PM
Sorry to do this, but this is another war. I was being patient, but you are beginning to aggrivate others. You are both returning to the same points over and over, give up, you two aren't going to change the mind of one another. Continue in PM's if you want, but keep it off the bords, please.